On 9/11 + 20: America won battles, Afghans lost the war

It has been 20 years since the attack that changed America, and in those 20 years not a single attack against us was planned and executed from Afghanistan.

This is a little harsh, but President Biden owns it

In case you forgot, that’s why we went in — to destroy the al-Qaeda terrorist network and bring to justice its head, Osama bin Laden.

Yes, mission accomplished.

In the 20 years following 9/11, during which 3,000 Americans died, only 100 have died in the homeland resulting from Islamist terror planned from abroad.

Contemplate that fact.

And before I go forward, a moment of silence for the 2,416 service members who died in Afghanistan, and our deepest thanks to the estimated 21,000 who were physically or mentally wounded. You protected America. You protected me. Mission accomplished. 

And yet, sadly, this 9/11 will find the white and black Taliban flag flying over Afghanistan, providing a PR victory for terror, and becoming a recruiting tool for nihilistic Islamic dead-enders the world over.  

Because of world-wide Islamist terror, which began decades before 9/11, we have been forced to surrender some routine freedoms. We have to show ID more than before, and boarding an airplane is time-consuming and frustrating. 

We’ve always known there are those in the world who hate us. 9/11 proved they can do something about it, something horrible. 

And they are not done with us yet.

I disagree with those who say the U.S. lost the war or was humiliated. When we had our troops on the ground in force, they won, not every single battle, but the majority and the terrorist expansion was reversed.

In the end, the war was lost but Afghanistan, not the U.S., lost the war.

At the start of our War of Independence, when asked what kind of government we had, Benjamin Franklin replied, “A republic, if you can keep it.”

We did. Afghanistan did not, despite the U.S. arming their troops, funding their government, opening schools to girls, and more. We did everything except wipe their ass. There was no lack of effort, money, blood, sweat, and tears. We gave Afghanistan everything it needed for success.

The failure is theirs, largely because of inept and corrupt leaders. Looking at them should make Americans feel gratitude about the quality of our patriarchy, the white European men who fashioned and sustained our government. We were truly blessed to have Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Hamilton, Franklin, Madison. 

—-

You remember where you were when you heard it, the astonishing news that an airliner had crashed into the North Tower of the World Trade Center at 8:46 a.m. 

That kind of an accident was shocking enough, but it turned into flabbergasted terror when the second plane crashed into the South Tower at 9:03 a.m., replacing the idea of an accident with the certainty that the homeland was attacked by air for the first time since December 7, 1941.

At my desk, I stopped what I had been doing and focused on the TV and the reporting of wire services.

At the time, I was writing a fairly successful gossip column, but that would not run the next day. The entire paper would be devoted to our generation’s day of infamy.

Some reporters headed for New York, before learning the city’s entrances were shut. A couple of reporters who were New York natives wanted to get to their city, and hunted for ways to get in. Not so easy when you understand that Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island are all islands and the bridges were closed. The Bronx could be entered from the north, but there was no assurance anyone could get from the north Bronx to the financial district. 

It was almost as if an atomic bomb had hit.

I remember dust-caked survivors running north, cops and firefighters barreling south, toward the stricken buildings that were soon to fall.

Some windows were shattered in my high school, a few blocks from the tragedy. 

The lower tip of the city was enveloped in smoke, obscuring the Statue of Liberty, watching helplessly. Under her gaze a flotilla of pleasure craft, and working ferries, tugboats, and other craft pushed to Lower Manhattan to rescue survivors, taking them to the safety of New Jersey.

The Pentagon was struck later and — let us never forget — the 40 hero passengers on United Airlines #93, who responded to Todd Beamer’s call to “Let’s roll!” and attacked their hijackers, crashing their plane in the Pennsylvania countryside at Shanksville rather than into the U.S. Capitol. 

We did not see that happen.

We did see jetliners strike the World Trade Center and the immediate result of the Pentagon being struck.

Amid the blizzard of images, the ones that freeze me are the ones of desperate Americans, with an inferno behind them, leaping from 100th floor windows to their deaths on the asphalt of the streets below.

I try to imagine what went through their minds as they leapt, and what they were thinking in the few seconds it took for them to meet their instant deaths.

The deaths of these innocent civilians is in the front of my mind when I ponder whether vengeance, and what kind, was appropriate.

I conclude we were justified in invading Afghanistan and breaking the Taliban, who were shielding the attackers.

It probably would have been best if we left after bin Laden was killed, but hindsight is always 20/20. 

I suspect presidents and war planners feared the Taliban would surge back.

A few weeks ago, we did leave — and the Taliban did surge back.

It is a very unhappy ending to our 20-year struggle to help Afghanistan stand up as a free nation.

No America “lost” Afghanistan. American gave Afghans the weapons and training they needed, but could not instill in them the will to fight.

Afghanistan lost itself.

12 thoughts on “On 9/11 + 20: America won battles, Afghans lost the war”

  1. HAPPY WEDNESDAY !!!
    Stu,
    What a mixed bag you wrote. I don’t know how you can make the statement that Afghanistan did not / has not attacked us in twenty years. Unless a terrorist leaves a note to be found, we can only surmise. It seems that some group always steps up for the credit. True or not, we’ll never know. For certain. We will not be invaded anytime soon by a standing army. Like many, I think that we are going to see more terrorism on our ground.
    As someone has said, “war is hell”. The troops that go into battle know their mission. They don’t like to pay twice for the same piece of real estate and they certainly don’t like to leave anyone behind. But this is real life. This is not a HBO special. John Wayne will not be saving the day.
    Politics suck ! We were not allowed to win Korea, Vietnam or any of these Middle Eastern battles that we have been involved in since Christ walked the earth. We go there to save the people from themselves. We never go far enough. We fight to a draw and at times, not even that. History proves that the troops on the ground are merely pawns in this game called war. Always was, always will be. Sure, modern technology is out there, and we fight with more equipment and less troops. That’s were the politics come in. Keep the war going so that we can run up the defense budget. Push a button and there goes a million dollar rocket. Launch aircraft and watch a billion dollars go up in the sky. And try to keep everyone at home in the dark, fat, dumb and happy.
    Tony

    1. I can’t prove a negative. If you think Afghans were behind a terror attack on homeland, you prove it. I have found NO evidence of such a plot.
      After WWII, we fought to a draw in Korea, we lost Vietnam, Reagan had a couple of meaningless escapades in the Caribbean, we won the Gulf War against Iraq and “won” against the Taliban until politicians reversed it. As previously noted, I wanted to keep troops in Afghanistan, a position opposed by both Left and Right, proving again I am neither.

      1. pallie,
        Sometimes you are a funny guy. “prove a negative’. OKAY out there. Show of hands. Who are Afghani terrorists ? Who is a card carrying member of ISIS ?
        You call it a draw. Don’t ever put on a uniform. We don’t fight for draws. We win on the battlefield and our politicians – all of them, hand us a loss !
        I am the one that is for ‘policing the world’ We keep troops in many country. For world defense, not police action. We are on every large body of water. Again for world defense. At any time, these forces can and do strike down terrorism. If we send in our Marines to any country to rid that country of terrorism. KEEP THEM THERE ! A force that is seen commands respect. First gain peace, then improvements. That has always been my stand. If you really want world peace, this is what it will take.
        Tony

  2. What I remember with anger and horror is the fact the CIA and the FBI never talked to each other. And if they had 9/11 MAY have been averted because each knew a different something of what was being planned, and could have deduced what was to come. Turf wars — politics– played a huge part in 9/11. Praise to those brave firemen who died, and to the passengers who brought the fourth plane down that was probably heading for the White House. What will happen in Afghanistan now is anybody’s guess.

  3. SHOCK, PRAYER & MEMORIAL

    Giant towers ensconced, graced by nature’s clear blue sky, suddenly shook without warning, then imploded, crumbled and cried 

    Poisonous rolling clouds, thundering down crowded Manhattan streets, unimaginable shocking visuals, witnessing dark thoughts of defeat

    Alas! my God in Heaven, I do not wish to believe, all of this carnage of Your humanity.  Still, I cannot turn away,  please tell me it’s not real, this sight that keeps repeating, this evil that I feel

    When will I heal sweet Jesus? My life’s not the same, all these nightmares and panic attacks, anxiety fraught with pain

    We come here each September, where once reined the depths of hell, calling out the innocents, and  tolling the memory bell
    No matter the distant future whatever it may have in store,  let us never forget that horrific day, the attack on our homeland shore 

  4. The fundamentalist Muslin belief system that is embedded in the psyches of the Taliban is the reason for the war. The non-believers are a sign of sin. The non-believers don’t have a right to live. Non-believers are infidels. Allah rewards Muslim warriors for eliminating non-believers. Bin-Laden declared war on us and we basically ignored him. The next time a fundamentalist Muslim group declares wars on the US we better pay attention. Fundamentalist Muslim schools are thriving in Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan that teach these hateful theories. Future Attacks will originate against the West and Israel by the students of these fundamentalist schools. Prevention and constant vigilance has to be our defense against future attacks. We can’t become complacent. Only 5% of the Muslim faith are fundamentalists. We need to work with the 95% to protect the US. The exodus was ugly and mismanaged. I believe the costs were overwhelming after 20 years. Let’s hope the next 20 years are safe and prosperous.

    1. You are correct on all points. In EVERY religion, the fundamentalists are the trouble makers. They can’t compromise, they believe, because THEY are following the word of God.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *